Jerry Simms

Arbitrator Allows Skyfall 7 Back On Turf Paradise Property, Says Hartunian

After Turf Paradise track owner Jerry Simms had locked Gary Hartunian's Skyfall 7 operating crew out of the property last weekend, an arbitrator sided with Skyfall 7 Friday allowing them back into the facility, Hartunian told TDN in a brief call Friday evening. "We've already got the keys," said Hartunian. While Hartunian and Skyfall 7 are allowed back onto the property, there remain key questions marks over the viability of a Turf Paradise meet that is scheduled to begin Nov. 27 under the tenure of Skyfall 7. In a notice...

[ Read More ]
“We Gave Him a Proposal”: Tom Ludt Talks Separate Turf Paradise Lease Offer

Former Turf Paradise general manager Tom Ludt responded Tuesday afternoon to a press release issued by Gary Hartunian through his lawyer, Mitchell Nelson, alleging that former management personnel attempted to "sabotage his company's operations and prevent the upcoming 2026-2027 racing season from proceeding as planned." In the statement, Hartunian argues he's not behind in his payments to the track's landlord, Jerry Simms, and that it's Simms who owes him money--some $3.2 million arising from alleged "undisclosed property damage, necessary repairs, and municipal and state penalties and fines" associated with conditions...

[ Read More ]
Horsemen, Commission Appreciate Productive Turf Paradise Offseason

Turf Paradise, which spent recent years mired in a never-ending cascade of controversy, is enjoying a quiet, productive summer of projects and improvements, according to reports from both the Arizona Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (AZHBPA) and the Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) during the commission's monthly meeting Thursday. "The Turf team is doing a wonderful job, improving all the areas, not only inside, but outside as well," said Brian Duncan, the AZRC's racing enforcement and operations manager. "The department does remain pleased with the steady progress they're making on the...

[ Read More ]
Focusing on Bringing People Back to the Track, Turf Paradise Appears Headed for a Brighter Future

Turf Paradise had to cram them in on the day of the GI Kentucky Derby Day. Every seat in the track was sold out and, including those who bought general admission tickets, the estimated crowd was 7,500. While most tracks draw big crowds for the Derby simulcast and live racing, this was something new for Turf Paradise. The facility had grown into such disrepair that no one had wanted to come. Things were so bad that, according to new GM Tom Ludt, most people living in the Phoenix area did...

[ Read More ]
Long-Term Optimism, Short-Term Concerns With Turf Paradise On Cusp of Regime Change

With Turf Paradise in the process of a racing permit transfer to a new leaseholder that puts the 69-year-old track on the cusp of a possible regime change, stakeholders who spoke about the longer-term future of racing in greater Phoenix were cautiously optimistic during Thursday's Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) meeting. But representatives of the Arizona Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (AZHBPA) did articulate short-term concerns that at times vacillated between glass-half-full and glass-half-empty, echoing a nagging tone of uncertainty familiar to anyone who has followed the ups and downs of...

[ Read More ]
Turf Paradise Reports Historically Low Fatality Rate

The 2024-2025 race meeting at Turf Paradise in Phoenix, Arizona, concluded on Kentucky Derby day May 3 with the lowest ever fatality rate in the 69-year history of the track, according to a release. For the entire meet, the track recorded a fatality rate of 0.73 per 1,000 starts and from the beginning of 2025 through the end of the meet, post a rate of just 0.24. The 2024 Jockey Club national average was 1.11/1,000, while the 2024 HISA national average was 0.90/1,000, the release stated. "Such accomplishments come about...

[ Read More ]
After Track Woes Delay Meet, Turf Paradise's First Week Of Racing Reported As Safe

After a nine-day delay to fix safety concerns that pushed back the opening of the 2024-25 racing season at Turf Paradise from Nov. 2 to Nov. 11, horsemen, jockeys, regulators and track management were all largely in concurrence Friday that the first four days of racing at the Arizona track this past Monday through Thursday were conducted in safe and sustainable fashion. The largely positive reviews and glowing articulations of cooperation at the Nov. 15 Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) meeting stood out in contrast to the contention and infighting that...

[ Read More ]
Audit: Years of Losses at Turf Paradise, But Track Stays Afloat From Personal Loans Simms Eventually Wants Repaid

A director of an independent accounting firm hired by the Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) to audit the financials of Turf Paradise as part of the track's three-year permit application testified at a Thursday meeting that if $24 million in federal and state subsidies from the COVID-19 pandemic gets backed out of the equation, Turf Paradise has operated at a net loss for the past three years. Sean Tanner, a certified public accountant who specializes in forensic accounting with Keegan Linscott & Associates, further told the AZRC that based upon projections...

[ Read More ]
Report: Turf Paradise Gets New Lease on Life

According to a report in the Daily Racing Form by Matt Hegarty, the owners of Turf Paradise and local horseman have reached a deal in which the track will run about 100 cards a year for the next three years. The track's future had been uncertain since owner Jerry Simms announced last November that the track would not be opening for its regularly scheduled six-month meet. Turf Paradise General Manager Vince Francia told the DRF that there will be four days of racing each week, starting with the first weekend...

[ Read More ]
Trouble In (Turf) Paradise: Sale Again Called Off, '24 Meet Still Planned

For the second time in four months, a reported sale of Turf Paradise has been called off. The track's current owner, Jerry Simms, broke the news at Friday's Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) meeting without disclosing details or being pressed by regulators to provide any additional information. Preparations for a planned Jan. 29-May 4 race meet are still underway, though, according to testimony from track officials, commission employees, and representatives of the Arizona Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (AZHBPA). The revelation that the deal was a no-go didn't seem to come...

[ Read More ]
Turf Paradise Approved to Run '24 Meet, Pending Sign-off by HISA Authority

Turf Paradise received unanimous but conditional approval from the Arizona Racing Commission (AZRC) on Tuesday to conduct a Jan. 29-May 4 race meet. The upcoming season, however, won't be run under the auspices of the new ownership group that has been reportedly trying to buy the Phoenix track for the last two months. Instead, Turf Paradise's current owner, Jerry Simms, will still be at the helm. Simms and Arizona horsemen have had an acrimonious business relationship for the better part of two decades. But Simms vowed during the Dec. 5...

[ Read More ]
The Week in Review: HBPA Tries to Derail HISA in Federal Court–But Also Wants Its Help in Arizona

If the saga over the supposedly pending sale of now-closed Turf Paradise was a soap opera, its title would surely be "AZ the World Turns." The state's racing is hanging in the balance amid an increasingly acrimonious long-term feud between the track's owner and horsemen, leading one trainer at last Thursday's Arizona Racing Commission meeting to liken the horse community's predicament to children "being used as pawns in a divorce battle" by vindictive parents on the verge of a nasty split. Although TDN's original story about that Oct. 12 commission...

[ Read More ]
X

Never miss another story from the TDN

Click Here to sign up for a free subscription.